Page 1 of 1

To Seal Fenders to Wall ... or not?

PostPosted: Tue Jul 10, 2018 10:50 pm
by Tim C.
I am almost ready to mount aluminum fenders to my sandwich foam/ply walls. I have locations noted where I have solid wood, to receive threaded inserts.
I am contemplating attaching the fenders such that there is a small gap between the fender and wall, through the use of 1/8 inch thick plastic washer. This should allow drainage and no water accumulated.
Has anyone tried this technique and have feedback on its success?
My experience with creating ease of drainage between wood parts on my cedar deck that I designed and built 25 years ago, and the success of this approach, has steered me to seriously contemplate this option.

Any other ideas or are people just laying down lots of caulking?

Re: To Seal Fenders to Wall ... or not?

PostPosted: Tue Jul 10, 2018 11:14 pm
by halfdome, Danny
Personally I wouldn't leave a gap as it will allow freeway driven rain to attack your door seals.

I always use fender welt between the fender and exterior wall but that's just for a vintage look.
My first two teardrops I used the "T" nut application and it worked fine but I forgot them on TD #3 and found out that was just fine.
This way I just drill the holes through the finished walls without having to hunt and peck where the "T" nuts are located.
I put 5 bolts on each fender, three of them you can see on the interior so I use chrome plated ones even though the mattress covers all of them but the top center one.

I've never had a water penetration issue doing it this way since I use a liberal amount of sealant in the holes and on the threads and pan head 3/8" bolts.
I also seal the under side of the fender to wall connection and spray rubber undercarriage sealant (Walmart sells it in a spray can) on the underside of the fender and the wall.
This way everything is sealed and looks black for the black tires.
:D Danny

Re: To Seal Fenders to Wall ... or not?

PostPosted: Wed Jul 11, 2018 9:22 am
by working on it
Tim C. wrote:I am almost ready to mount aluminum fenders to my sandwich foam/ply walls. I have locations noted where I have solid wood, to receive threaded inserts.
I am contemplating attaching the fenders such that there is a small gap between the fender and wall, through the use of 1/8 inch thick plastic washer. This should allow drainage and no water accumulated....
  • I have no experience with attaching fenders directly to either foam or wood trailer walls, but many years of experience with using steel fenders attached to trailer frames, using inner shields of steel, or hard plastic, on mostly open trailers. I've seen, and experienced damaged fenders, from encountering large road debris... or in one case where a tire blew-out, and the shredded tire had enough force to damage my thick steel fender (I was driving at 75+ mph), but my race car on the trailer was untouched, saved by the inner fender shield.
  • If you need to attach your teardrop or TTT fender directly to the wall itself, and not isolated from it, by frame or suspension mounts, then use heavy-duty hardware, and use an inner shield (backing plate) in any case. Using 1/8" spacers might allows water to drain from the fender-wall interface, but if a backing plate is used, it will make the spacer unneeded. On my squareback trailer, I used both a frame-mount, a backing plate, and also left a 1" between cabin wall and fender assembly; no water or dirt ever touches the wall, protected by the isolated fender (I can easily clean my wall behind the fender, also, with a thin sponge).
  • My trailer is an odd width, 50", and my floor is 48" wide (my walls sit on top of the floor, giving me 46.5" inside cabin width), so that left me with the 1" gap between frame edge and walls, making attachment directly to the sidewalls infeasible. And, with my first axle not having brake backing plates, the free-floating fender assembly that I would've used (I've admired them on many street-rods, and wanted to build one) was impossible also. So, frame-mounting was the best choice, in my case. Since my design intent was for a heavy-duty, semi-offroad trailer, I bought heavy steel fenders with optional backing plates, welded the plates on, and welded (not by me, but by a pro,,,I didn't weld when he was available!), and welded them onto the frame in five spots (not a continuous weld, to avoid warpage), with stiffening bars (1" steel angle) on front and rear fender edges (also welded to the frame). Very strong, very protective!
  • fender mounting rationale pictured.jpg
    fender mounting rationale pictured.jpg (247.83 KiB) Viewed 1756 times
    alternative fender-mounting ideas; I recommend using an inner shield on all fenders

Re: To Seal Fenders to Wall ... or not?

PostPosted: Thu Jul 12, 2018 1:20 pm
by Swan
I would never seal the fender to the wall . I have bolted mine on with plastic bolts in four spots. I use plastic as I want the fender to break away if the tire was to blow out. They are strong enough to hold the fender on without vibration but they are no means a seat or a step. A fender bolted though a wall can get major damage from the repeated slapping of a half mounted tread .

Re: To Seal Fenders to Wall ... or not?

PostPosted: Thu Jul 12, 2018 2:26 pm
by halfdome, Danny
We had a blow out at 70 mph last summer.
Image
No damage to the teardrop or fender.
The black on the fender edge is where the tire rubbed the under coating off.
:D Danny

Re: To Seal Fenders to Wall ... or not?

PostPosted: Fri Jul 13, 2018 10:16 am
by noseoil
Since the fenders were attached to the frame already & matched the tires pretty well, I left the gap in place. I did add a bit of diamond plate (attached to the aluminum skin with stainless screws & sealed) to the inside of the opening against the trailer. Didn't want any rocks bouncing off of the .040" aluminum skin & it works well enough.

153777

Re: To Seal Fenders to Wall ... or not?

PostPosted: Fri Jul 13, 2018 1:12 pm
by halfdome, Danny
Swan wrote:I would never seal the fender to the wall . I have bolted mine on with plastic bolts in four spots. I use plastic as I want the fender to break away if the tire was to blow out. They are strong enough to hold the fender on without vibration but they are no means a seat or a step. A fender bolted though a wall can get major damage from the repeated slapping of a half mounted tread .


What if the fender completely broke away and hit a car or motorcycle behind you? :frightened:
There's a possibility it could hit a windshield or someone on a motorcycle.
:D Danny