Page 2 of 2

Re: removable hard top vs soft top

PostPosted: Mon Sep 16, 2013 7:46 pm
by myoung
Chuckles wrote:Going with option #1.

Now, I am thinking about putting a removable section in the roof for a screened sun/moon roof. I have seen some that were done using canvas fastened with snaps (the X-2 I believe). I was thinking of putting a lip (say 3/4" tall) on the opening then making a hardtop that can be hinged on one side or removed in really warm weather. I would just move the fantastic fan back to just above the door and put a removable section between the upper storage cabinet and the door.

Has anyone used a hard top? I was thinking it would be easier to seal, especially when travelling. In my mind I was thinking it could be fastened down tight from inside the tear. Does anyone here have any experience with removable tops?

and no...thats not what I meant. :lol: you can remove your mind from the gutter now!


When I built my pop-up, a 4x8-foot hinged roof, I had expected to put rip-stop nylon and screening on three sides. Now that I've had the trailer for a few years, I have found no reason for enclosing the sides. During the day, I leave the top open fully or just partially depending upon wind or sunlight or the need for headroom while cooking. At night, I just lower the top with a push button and the seal around the edges is sufficient to keep out rain or wind. I don't think I'll ever bother with sides on the top. Just a nuisance and it would block the view to boot.

Re: removable hard top vs soft top

PostPosted: Mon Sep 16, 2013 9:49 pm
by Chuckles
myoung wrote:
Chuckles wrote:Going with option #1.

Now, I am thinking about putting a removable section in the roof for a screened sun/moon roof. I have seen some that were done using canvas fastened with snaps (the X-2 I believe). I was thinking of putting a lip (say 3/4" tall) on the opening then making a hardtop that can be hinged on one side or removed in really warm weather. I would just move the fantastic fan back to just above the door and put a removable section between the upper storage cabinet and the door.

Has anyone used a hard top? I was thinking it would be easier to seal, especially when travelling. In my mind I was thinking it could be fastened down tight from inside the tear. Does anyone here have any experience with removable tops?

and no...thats not what I meant. :lol: you can remove your mind from the gutter now!


When I built my pop-up, a 4x8-foot hinged roof, I had expected to put rip-stop nylon and screening on three sides. Now that I've had the trailer for a few years, I have found no reason for enclosing the sides. During the day, I leave the top open fully or just partially depending upon wind or sunlight or the need for headroom while cooking. At night, I just lower the top with a push button and the seal around the edges is sufficient to keep out rain or wind. I don't think I'll ever bother with sides on the top. Just a nuisance and it would block the view to boot.



In the end I built a slouchy so there was no need for a pop-up section. Its still on the list of possibilities for teardrop #2 ;) I'm already forming plans in my head for a smaller teardrop for my son or daughter to use on camping trips. This will probably be more traditional in design except for a screened sun/moon roof.

Chuck