Page 2 of 5

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Sat Aug 04, 2018 5:50 pm
by Pmullen503
The foam will expand if you can get it to the temperature you need to bend it but you can then sand it fair afterwards.

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Sun Aug 05, 2018 6:02 am
by GPW
... since we will only be bending in small increments at a time ( creating a much larger curve, small bend by small bend bend ) we only need to heat a little area of the Foam and in that area only the top and bottom surfaces … The middle of the foam doesn’t feel the full tension and compression forces and being thnner , just goes along with the bend …The top (outside of the curve is being stretched , the inner curve (inside is being shoved together , or compressed) Just a little heat makes this process easier .
...and then it cools completely in a minute , no waiting … stays bent in that shape permanently .
Just a couple cheapest Harbor Freight heat guns and a “bending jig” is all we need … And as soon as I get the FoamStream repairs finished, I’m going to make a jig for bending 1” & 2” foam , and a You Tube video of the process … ( bending 1” will be EASY )

Anyone wanting to test this without much investment , just lay a piece of foam over a table edge , heat along that edge with a heat gun ( or a kettle of boiling water = 212F ) and apply pressure to the outer end till it bends where you want … hold it there till it cools … and then you’re done … If you mark the foam with a line across every few inches, and bend slightly at each mark , you end up with a nice Curve …




Trust me , once you bend your first piece of foam to the shape you want , you’ll see how easy and quick it is , and with no mess to clean up or track in the house …( and have to clean that up too)… It does take some help , but it is Not difficult .

I know all this seems as incredible as the original idea of someone making a camper trailer out of foam ( we know that works, now ;) )… but if we all work through this , well be able to essentially build any shape we want …

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Sun Aug 05, 2018 7:52 pm
by Tomterrific
You guys could come over and put the foam on my blacktop driveway! :-) Seriously, the comments about foam being slow to heat and slow to bend should be obvious, foam being a super insulator. I could not get my roof ply to bend so I pre bent it half way over night. I suppose foam could be tented in clear plastic sheet in the sun over blacktop and a simple jig putting gentle pressure on the bend. A heat gun would then work better after several hours in the hot sun.

An interesting experiment as I have never liked the idea of kerfing the foam.

Tt

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Tue Aug 07, 2018 12:37 pm
by GPW
This is interesting … https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OwABZT2pIn8 in some pics , you can see the heat gun handy …

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Thu Aug 16, 2018 10:03 am
by DaddyJeep
GPW wrote:( bending 1” will be EASY )


I did my first test of this process last night and was not blown away at how easy it was. My camper has a radius all the way around the edges so I will need to bend a fair amount of 1" foam.

IMG_20180814_224550.jpg
IMG_20180814_224550.jpg (189.29 KiB) Viewed 2093 times


The spacing between my framing is 21" - 23" so that is the size of piece I will be bending. Maybe picking up a second heat gun will help instead of going back and forth. I am anxious to see your video of how easy it is to bend 1" foam GPW. :R

IMG_20180815_220115.jpg
IMG_20180815_220115.jpg (143.03 KiB) Viewed 2093 times

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Thu Aug 16, 2018 3:05 pm
by Aguyfromohio
Thanks for sharing your actual shop-floor test.
I still think the idea has a lot of merit, but getting even heat on the foam to a precise temperature will be a trick.

Using engineering-speak, the foam has both low specific heat and a low thermal conductivity. The low specific heat means it changes temp fast in both directions. Put too much heat gun on it and it melts right away. Move the heat gun away and the foam temp races back down to room temp, so its gone hard again when you move away to heat the bit just over a few inches. The low thermal conductivity means that the heat just won't spread out from the spot you are aiming the heat gun. To use a simile, our foam is a lot more like a loaf of bread and a lot less like a pan of water. That's why I think an oven will work better, like it does for bread. The oven is the heat gun with a temperature controller blowing into a tent with the foam inside.

The original poster GPW might have trained themselves to developed just the right touch and feel with that heat gun to dance the gun around just right, like the skills a good car painter develops for using the spray gun.

Me, I'd build that tent/oven, turn it on at breakfast, and check the foam after lunch.

Of course there is always a few approaches that can work. I suppose if we put a strip of thick metal (high specific heat, high thermal mass, high thermal conductivity) laid it onto the foam, and used the heat gun on the metal, it would evenly heat the foam underneath and keep the temp stable.

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Thu Aug 16, 2018 4:05 pm
by GPW
I just keep the gun moving backing forth with an eye on the surface … any melting (shininess) or bubbling means we’re too close or not moving fast enough … but then again , we’re only heating a small line across the foam , not a large area which would be subject to the science "a guy” was talking about … ^

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Thu Aug 16, 2018 7:33 pm
by Pmullen503
GPW wrote:I just keep the gun moving backing forth with an eye on the surface … any melting (shininess) or bubbling means we’re too close or not moving fast enough … but then again , we’re only heating a small line across the foam , not a large area which would be subject to the science "a guy” was talking about … ^


You are just going to have to show us how it can be done.

I'm thinking steam with a box to keep the heat in. I've measured how long it takes for the heat to soak through a 1/4" of XPS and I think it's going to take an hour or more for 2" foam.

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Thu Aug 16, 2018 10:22 pm
by lrrice
In the drawing above of the bender , what about using a steel pipe and forcing hot air or water through it.

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Fri Aug 17, 2018 3:54 am
by GPW
The bender unit has been tried many ways by the RC guys , but the simplest is still the best …

Now that we’ve caught up with the FoamStream renovation , we’ll have to construct a bender for the 1” foam out of scrap … Hopefully we can make a quick video … Stay tuned ...

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Fri Aug 17, 2018 8:10 am
by GPW
“You are just going to have to show us how it can be done.” …. https://youtu.be/5WVKttqb6HQ ;)

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Fri Aug 17, 2018 8:41 am
by GPW
… and to the extreme … sorry about the low rez video , new camera … :duh:

Any questions ???

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Fri Aug 17, 2018 9:35 am
by Homebrewer25
Looks pretty easy, but what would be your approach to bending a 60" wide piece of 2" thick foam?

It seems that as you pass back and forth over that width there would be significant heat loss and would take a long time to get hot enough (if ever :) ).

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Fri Aug 17, 2018 10:51 am
by GPW
You’ve seen it !!!!

For big sheets … Two people with heat guns , one on top ,one on the bottom , despite what you think it will do , you can obviously see it will bend , that’s just with a little 1000Watt hobby heat gun … Then you need one person doing the pushing/bending … 3 people … That’s why it may require the help of friends or family for big sheets … ( and a little PRACTICE handling a heat gun or you’ll surely scorch it if you’re not paying attention... :frightened: )

The whole secret is to not be greedy or rushed and try to do too much at one time ( a No No ) …. you can actually FEEL it letting go , bending a little at a time … With two people heating top and bottom simultaneously it will go much quicker…

Now what to do with this 1” foam Taco … ??? :o

Watch the video … https://youtu.be/5WVKttqb6HQ

Re: Let’s Heat bend Foam … Please !!! No more kerfing ...

PostPosted: Fri Aug 17, 2018 10:59 am
by GPW
Now I don’t know about heat loss in TN , but here in LA it’s Hot as Heck , my pickup truck emblem melting ... :frightened: There’s NO heat loss here … :sweaty: Maybe don’t even need a heat gun . :thinking: